How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident in California?

How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident in California?

After a car accident, one of your first financial concerns may be: How much will my insurance go up?

In California, the answer depends largely on who caused the accident. If you were not at fault, your insurer generally cannot increase your premium because of that accident. If you were at least 51% responsible, however, your insurance costs could increase when your policy renews.

There is no single statewide percentage that applies to every driver. Your increase depends on your insurance company, driving record, and the circumstances of the crash.

At Sally Morin Personal Injury Lawyers, we help people who have suffered serious injuries in California traffic accidents. Here’s what you should know about insurance increases, California’s fault rules, and how to protect yourself financially.

 

How Much Does Insurance Increase After an Accident?

An at-fault accident can make car insurance considerably more expensive, but the exact increase varies.

For example, here’s how different hypothetical premium increases would affect a driver currently paying $200 per month.

Premium increase New monthly premium Additional annual cost
10% $220 $240
20% $240 $480
30% $260 $720
40% $280 $960
50% $300 $1,200

These are mathematical illustrations, not predictions or California average increases.

Several factors influence your actual premium:

  • Fault: Whether your insurer determines you were principally responsible for the accident.
  • Driving history: Previous chargeable accidents and violations may affect your rate.
  • Insurance company: Insurers use different approved rating plans.
  • Accident consequences: Injuries and property damage can determine whether an accident counts against your driving record for insurance-rating purposes.
  • Discount eligibility: An at-fault accident may affect your California Good Driver Discount.

The most reliable way to determine your increase is to request a renewal estimate and an explanation from your insurance company.

 

How Much Will My Insurance Go Up With an At-Fault Accident in California?

California uses a specific standard for determining whether an accident can affect your insurance premium.

Under California’s insurance regulations, you may be considered principally at fault when your actions were at least 51% responsible for causing an accident that meets the applicable injury or property-damage criteria.

The California Department of Insurance confirms that insurers may apply an accident surcharge when a driver is at least 51% at fault.

What if you’re only partially responsible?

Consider these examples:

  • 0% at fault: The accident should not produce an accident-related surcharge.
  • 20% at fault: You are not principally at fault under the 51% standard.
  • 51% at fault: The accident may become chargeable if the other regulatory requirements are satisfied.
  • 100% at fault: A qualifying accident may result in a premium increase.

This distinction matters because California’s comparative negligence rules for personal injury compensation are different from its insurance-rating rules.

You might share some responsibility for a collision without meeting the threshold for an at-fault insurance surcharge.

 

Will My Insurance Go Up if the Accident Was Not My Fault?

Generally, no. California protects drivers from accident-related premium increases when they were not principally at fault.

California’s Proposition 103 insurance framework requires insurers to consider driving safety records under regulated rating rules.

However, your overall premium might still increase at renewal for unrelated reasons, such as an approved companywide rate adjustment.

If your insurance goes up after a not-at-fault accident, ask your insurer to identify the reason.

What if the insurance company incorrectly blames you?

You can challenge its determination.

California regulations require insurers to provide information about qualifying fault investigations, including the basis for assigning fault and the driver’s right to seek reconsideration.

Useful evidence may include accident photographs, witness statements, police reports, and other documentation showing how the collision occurred.

 

How Much Does Insurance Go Up After a Minor Accident?

A minor accident does not automatically mean a minor insurance increase.

California’s rules generally require an accident involving only property damage to exceed a specified threshold before it can count as a principally at-fault accident for rating purposes.

For accidents occurring on or after December 11, 2011, that threshold is generally more than $1,000 in total property damage. Different considerations apply when someone is injured or killed.

For example, a small parking-lot scrape with $400 in total damage may be treated differently from a collision causing $3,000 in damage.

Do not assume that paying for repairs yourself will automatically prevent an accident from being considered by an insurer.

 

At-Fault vs. Not-at-Fault Accidents: Insurance Consequences

Situation Potential insurance consequence
You caused a qualifying accident Premium surcharge may apply
Another driver caused the accident No accident-related surcharge for you
You were less than 51% responsible Generally not principally at fault
Minor property damage below the applicable threshold May not qualify as a chargeable accident
You lose Good Driver Discount eligibility Premium may increase
You file a claim after a hit-and-run Fault and applicable rating rules determine treatment

The key takeaway: Filing an insurance claim and being responsible for an accident are not the same thing.

 

How Long Does an Accident Affect Your Insurance in California?

An at-fault accident can affect insurance pricing for several years.

Many insurers consider accident history over approximately three to five years, depending on the applicable rating rules and circumstances.

However, that does not mean your premium automatically returns to its original amount on a particular date.

Your future premium may also reflect changes in coverage, approved insurer rates, and your driving history.

For more information, read our guide on how long an accident stays on your driving record.

 

How to Lower Car Insurance After an Accident

You may not be able to eliminate an appropriate at-fault surcharge, but you can take steps to control your insurance costs.

  1. Compare insurance quotes. Different companies may offer different premiums for the same coverage.
  2. Ask about available discounts. Review eligibility for applicable driving, vehicle, or policy discounts.
  3. Consider increasing your deductible. A higher deductible can reduce premiums, but increases what you pay when you make a covered claim.
  4. Review your coverage. Avoid removing important protection simply to reduce your monthly bill.
  5. Check the fault determination. If the insurer assigned fault incorrectly, request reconsideration.
  6. Maintain a safe driving record. Avoiding additional violations and chargeable accidents can help over time.

California generally prohibits using personal credit scores to determine private-passenger automobile insurance premiums, so improving your credit score is not a California-specific solution to an accident surcharge.

The California Department of Insurance’s automobile insurance guide provides additional information about coverage and premium factors.

 

What to Do After a Car Accident: 6 Steps to Protect Your Rights

Your actions after a collision can affect both your insurance claim and your ability to recover compensation for serious injuries.

  1. Check for injuries. Call 911 when emergency assistance is needed. Seek appropriate medical attention.
  2. Document the accident. Photograph the vehicles, visible damage, road conditions, and relevant traffic signs if it is safe to do so.
  3. Exchange information. Collect the other driver’s contact and insurance details.
  4. Report the collision. Notify your insurer according to your policy requirements. Complete any legally required police or DMV reports.
  5. Avoid guessing about faults. Give accurate information without speculating about responsibility.
  6. Preserve your records. Keep medical bills, repair estimates, insurance correspondence, and evidence of missed work.

For additional guidance, see how to report a car accident in California.

 

What Happens if You’re Seriously Injured in an Accident?

Insurance premiums are only one part of the financial consequences of a serious collision.

If another driver caused your injuries, you may be entitled to compensation for medical expenses, lost earnings, future treatment, and pain and suffering, depending on the circumstances.

At Sally Morin Personal Injury Lawyers, we focus on serious traffic accident injuries. Our work includes investigating liability, negotiating with insurers, and addressing medical bills and liens as part of the injury claim.

Do You Have a Personal Injury Case?

If you suffered serious injuries because of another driver’s negligence, you may have grounds for a personal injury claim.

Use our interactive Do I Have a Personal Injury Case? assessment below to explore factors that may affect your potential claim.

Interactive Case Assessment

This assessment helps you consider your injuries, the accident circumstances, and possible next steps. It does not determine your insurance premium or replace a legal evaluation.

 

Real Settlement Example: $475,000 Recovery After a Serious Injury

The financial impact of a serious injury can extend far beyond immediate medical expenses.

In one published case, Sally Morin Personal Injury Lawyers represented a Bay Area nurse practitioner who suffered severe injuries after falling over a dangerously low ledge at his apartment building.

He sustained hip and pelvic fractures that required emergency surgery.

Our team investigated the property’s dangerous condition, evaluated the client’s injuries, and considered his lost earnings and future earning capacity.

The case ultimately resolved through mediation for $475,000.

Although this was a premises liability case rather than a car accident, it illustrates why evaluating the full consequences of a serious injury matters.

Read the full $475,000 slip-and-fall settlement story.

Every case depends on its individual facts. Past results do not guarantee or predict future outcomes.

 

How Personal Injury Settlements Really Work

Worried about what happens after an insurance claim is filed?

Watch our video, How Injury Settlements Really Work, to learn more about the personal injury settlement process in California and why understanding the value of an injury claim is different from calculating an insurance premium increase.

 

What Our Clients Say

Choosing legal representation after a serious accident is an important decision. Hearing about other clients’ experiences can help you understand what matters during the process.

Read Amy R.‘s review of Sally Morin Personal Injury Lawyers on Yelp

Read Mike B.‘s review of Sally Morin Personal Injury Lawyers on Yelp

Client experiences vary. Testimonials do not predict or guarantee a particular result.

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Insurance Increases After an Accident

1. Will my insurance increase if I file a claim but wasn’t at fault?
Generally, California insurers cannot apply an accident-related surcharge when you were not principally at fault. Your premium may still change for unrelated reasons.

2. Can my insurance go up after an accident with no injuries?
Yes, if you were principally at fault and the property damage meets the applicable threshold. Not every minor collision qualifies.

3. Does a hit-and-run increase my insurance?
Not automatically. If you were not principally at fault, California’s protections against accident-related surcharges generally apply. Keep evidence supporting your account of the collision.

4. Will my insurance increase immediately after an accident?
An applicable surcharge generally affects your premium at renewal rather than changing what you already paid for the current policy term.

5. Can I dispute an at-fault determination?
Yes. Ask your insurer for the written explanation and reconsideration process. Provide supporting evidence if you believe its decision was incorrect.

 

Get Help After a Serious California Car Accident

If you’ve suffered serious injuries in a California traffic accident, your concerns may go well beyond next year’s insurance bill.

At Sally Morin Personal Injury Lawyers, we help seriously injured people pursue compensation while handling the legal and insurance aspects of their injury claims.

We take a selective approach to cases and work toward fair settlements, with litigation available when necessary.

Focus on your recovery. We’ll help you understand your legal options.

About the author
Sally Morin

When life throws you a curveball—a serious injury in a traffic accident—you need more than just a lawyer.
View author bio

See how much your case may be worth.

Get started with a free case evaluation now.